Methodology · 9Q-AIA 1.1

Trace every assumption to the result.

An illustrative economic comparison with visible costs, guarded inputs and explicitly provisional decision rules.

Decision basis and horizon

All results cover the next 12 months in USD, without discounting, financing, taxes, residual value or automatic inflation. Benefits assume 52 weeks of operation at the entered average adoption. Adjust inputs for realistic operating time and rollout delays. No estimate is independently verified.

Buy compares a new investment with the realistic alternative. Renew compares the next period of continued use with operating without it. Upgrade requires only incremental costs, hours and revenue above the existing plan; common costs and benefits are excluded. Cancel compares continuing with stopping now, after exit and remaining obligations. Labels identify the basis, and Cancel uses its separate comparison to drive the next step.

Only future costs belong in the investment case. Include future internal labor, implementation, training and recurring support. Exclude sunk, non-refundable amounts already spent. For cancellation, include future contract commitments that cannot be avoided in the cancellation cost field.

Cost bridge

Base recurring cost = monthly cost × 12.

Price-increase cost = monthly cost × increase rate × (13 − effective month).

Total modeled cost C = base recurring cost + price-increase cost + future setup and implementation.

The effective month is an integer from 1 to 12 inclusive. An increase in month 7 applies to six monthly payments; month 1 applies to all 12. Set the increase to zero when none occurs. If monthly cost includes expenses whose prices do not rise, use an equivalent blended increase across that total. Every active assumption is visible in the calculator.

Benefit bridge and overlap

Cash savings H = monthly cash expenses genuinely eliminated × 12.

Capacity S = weekly hours saved at full adoption × 52 × hourly value × usable-capacity rate × average adoption.

Attributed margin G = annual influenced revenue at full adoption × gross-margin rate × attributable share × average adoption.

Counted variable benefit V = max(S, G) when benefits overlap; otherwise S + G.

Total economic value = H + V. Net economic value = H + V − C.

ROI % = 100 × (H + V − C) ÷ C, only when C > 0.

Rates are percentages divided by 100. Enter hours and influenced revenue before adoption is applied to avoid discounting twice. Cash savings are assumed independently realizable at the entered amount. Do not also count removed payroll as saved capacity. Capacity is noncash unless redeployed or removed; therefore headline ROI is economic ROI, not a cash-flow return. The overlap rule avoids summing the two stated benefits but cannot detect every form of double counting.

Break-even adoption

Let V₁₀₀ be the variable benefit using 100% adoption. If H ≥ C, break-even adoption is 0%, including the zero-benefit/zero-cost case. Otherwise, if V₁₀₀ > 0, adoption needed = 100 × (C − H) ÷ V₁₀₀. A result above 100% is unreachable within the model. If V₁₀₀ = 0 and H < C, break-even is unreachable. Values are never clipped into a misleading feasible range. ROI with zero cost is undefined, not 0%.

Cancellation comparison

Net advantage of cancellation = future investment cost avoided − one-time exit cost − other unavoidable/replacement costs − all modeled economic benefits lost.

Positive favors cancellation under the entered assumptions; negative favors continuing. The model assumes all benefits stop and all investment costs can be avoided, except commitments re-entered as unavoidable cancellation costs. Returning expenses already represented by lost cash savings must not be added again. If cancellation preserves benefits or causes other losses, this simple model is insufficient and needs a tailored comparison. Exit cost is counted fully in this comparison and never amortized into the investment ROI.

Sensitivity scenarios

Costs and hard cash savings stay fixed. In the lower-benefit scenario, capacity is multiplied by 0.65 × 0.60 = 0.39 and attributed margin by 0.65 × 0.50 = 0.325 before applying the overlap rule. In the higher-benefit scenario, both are multiplied by 1.20. These arbitrary stress factors are visible heuristics; they are not calibrated forecasts, confidence intervals, guaranteed floors or ceilings. The cancellation comparison uses the base case only.

Exact next-step rules, in order

  1. Any unresolved risk flag overrides a positive recommendation and asks for resolution. This includes policy, portability, lock-in and lack of an accountable owner.
  2. In Cancel mode, a positive cancellation advantage suggests investigating cancellation; zero or negative suggests reviewing the case for continuing.
  3. For other modes, Not purchased or Under 30 days suggests a measured pilot.
  4. With zero modeled cost, review the zero-cost assumption; percentage ROI is undefined.
  5. If lower-benefit ROI is strictly above 15%, self-reported readiness is at least 65/100 and entered adoption reaches break-even, consider a controlled purchase, renewal or staged upgrade according to the selected intent.
  6. Otherwise, if base net value is positive and readiness is below 65, improve implementation readiness.
  7. Otherwise, if base ROI is below −25% and tenure exceeds one year, rework the investment case.
  8. All other cases ask the operator to test uncertain assumptions.

These thresholds have no published empirical calibration. Readiness is a respondent judgment, not a measured coordination score. The calculator cannot establish policy compliance, security, contract rights or investment suitability. It does not execute purchases, renewals, upgrades or cancellations.

Worked example

The prefilled example uses $500 per month, a 5% increase starting in month 7 and $2,500 of future setup: $6,000 + $150 + $2,500 = $8,650 cost. Monthly savings of $300 produce $3,600 annual cash savings. Eight weekly hours × 52 × $55 × 60% usability × 55% adoption = $7,550.40 capacity. $12,000 influenced revenue × 55% margin × 30% attribution × 55% adoption = $1,089 attributed margin.

With overlap checked, counted benefits are $3,600 + max($7,550.40, $1,089) = $11,150.40. Net value is $2,500.40 and base ROI is approximately 28.9%. Lower-benefit ROI is −24.3%; higher-benefit ROI is 46.4%. Break-even adoption is approximately 36.8%. With a $1,500 exit cost and no other cancellation cost, cancellation advantage is $8,650 − $1,500 − $11,150.40 = −$4,000.40. The 55/100 readiness assumption yields a provisional suggestion to improve implementation readiness.

Input checks and privacy

All numbers must be present, finite and nonnegative. Percentage fields and readiness accept 0–100; effective month accepts whole numbers 1–12. Monetary amounts, hours and hourly value have explicit upper bounds to reject implausibly large input and numerical overflow; those bounds are technical safeguards, not industry benchmarks. Invalid or blank input suppresses every result and recommendation. Calculations stay in active page memory and are not saved or transmitted.

Version history

9Q-AIA 1.1 · September 19, 2026 — Published the full cost bridge, price timing, sensitivity factors and decision rules. Separated future costs from sunk spending and cancellation costs. Made decision modes explicit, corrected units, validated inputs, handled zero cost and unreachable break-even, made every risk flag override positive recommendations, and removed the unsupported numerical Value score.

Legacy 9Q-AIA 1.0 · July 26, 2026 — Included half-year price escalation and one-third of exit cost in annual cost without exposing them in quick mode. Its default cost was $9,150 and default ROI about 21.9%. Version 1.1 removes that hidden $500 annualized exit amount; this explains the different default result. Neither version establishes empirical decision accuracy.

Run the AI Investment Audit